The Subversive Role of Excessive External Shear in Concealing Lensing Anomalies

Abstract

To best reproduce observed multiply-lensed lensed images, lens models usually incorporate shear attributed to objects unrelated to the lensing galaxy (i.e., external shear): whether it be neighbouring galaxies not explicitly included in the lens model or other cosmic structures along the sightline. When constrained solely by the positions of image counterparts, such lens models, even those utilising simple ellipsoidal mass distributions, can satisfactorily -- if not near perfectly -- reproduce the observed image positions, but often leave significant differences in flux ratios between the predicted and observed images. For the narrow-line regions (NLRs) of quasars, which are too large to be affected by micro-lensing from stars in the lensing galaxy, the flux ratio anomalies thus left are commonly attributed to small-scale structures (sub-structures) in Dark Matter associated with the lensing galaxy. Here, we show that external shear can always resolve, among the quadruply-lensed quasar NLRs studied, position anomalies in lens models constrained solely by the observed image positions, and in addition reduce although not fully resolving flux ratio anomalies when constrained by both the observed image positions and flux ratios -- provided, usually, that the external shear incorporated have strengths that far exceed (as is the common practise) those typically inferred from weak lensing along general sightlines (i.e., cosmic shear). Our work highlights the subversive role of excessive external shear in concealing lensing anomalies, undermining inferences on the characteristics of Dark Matter sub-structures -- and, correspondingly, the nature (mass and temperature) of the Dark Matter particle -- when not sensibly incorporated into lens models.